Methodology

What an alert is. A player prop price at a listed book that sits at least 3% above the fair price. Fair means the bookmaker's margin removed from a sharp reference: the sharp market price, the price at the sharpest sportsbook, when it quotes the same line (tier A), otherwise market consensus, the median across several books (tier B). A market with neither reference is never priced and never alerted. A book that is itself part of the consensus is never graded against a consensus that includes it: on tier B it is graded against the other members only, and only when enough of them quote the line; otherwise it is alerted against the sharp market price alone.

When an alert can post. No earlier than three hours before the scheduled tip, only on a price observed within the last 15 minutes against a reference observed within the last 15 minutes, once per player-market-line-book-side per game. Anything computed above 6% is treated as suspect and never posted: real edges are small.

How it is graded. Closing line value (CLV) = fair closing probability × the alerted decimal price − 1, the percentage by which the alerted price beat the fair price at tip-off. The close is the reference as observed in the last minutes before the scheduled tip, devigged with the same method as at bet time. If the reference was not quoting the same line at tip, the alert gets no close and is counted as such, never dropped. Nothing is graded by whether a bet won. In the record's by-sport split, a sport with fewer than 50 graded alerts is marked “too early to read”: its numbers are shown, but that few alerts say little yet.

What else is recorded. Thirty and sixty seconds after every alert the book is re-read: held, better, worse or gone. The full market snapshot at fire time is stored with every alert and is what the odds screen shows. A “tip moved” mark on a ledger row means the feed changed the game’s scheduled tip after the alert fired; the close stays anchored to the tip recorded at alert time, and the mark shows both times (and, when the live feed saw it, when the game was first seen started).

On the odds screen. Any price whose computed edge is above 6% is shown in mist with a "suspect" tag, never in green, in every column including Best EV: real edges are small, and a 6%+ number is usually a stale or one-sided price. Alerts post no earlier than three hours before tip. The alerted price is re-read 30 and 60 seconds after every alert; the counts are in the record section.

Sports. NBA player points, rebounds and assists; NHL player points, assists and shots on goal; NFL player passing yards, passing touchdowns, rushing yards, receptions and receiving yards; UFC moneylines; EPL game totals and moneylines; UCL game totals and moneylines; La Liga game totals and moneylines; Serie A game totals and moneylines; Bundesliga game totals and moneylines; Ligue 1 game totals and moneylines; MLS game totals and moneylines; Liga MX game totals and moneylines. Every sport runs through the same pipeline against the same sharp market reference, the same rules and the same grading, and every alert is on the record from the night its sport went live, losses included. A row of any sport but the NBA is marked with the sport on the odds screen and the history page. The NHL, NFL, UFC and soccer thresholds are provisional: they are the NBA calibration carried over, and they are tuned from the record as it accrues, never from results.

Game-line alerts. Where the sharp market prices a game line on every side (game totals: EPL, UCL, La Liga, Serie A, Bundesliga, Ligue 1, MLS, Liga MX; moneylines: UFC, EPL, UCL, La Liga, Serie A, Bundesliga, Ligue 1, MLS, Liga MX) the same rules apply with no player: the row is the game, the subject of the alert is the match total or the team or fighter named on it, the fair price is the same devig of the sharp market's sides, the close is the sharp market price at tip-off graded by the same method, and the 6% phantom line holds. A moneyline is priced on its own named sides, never as an over or under. Teams and fighters are the names the feed carries, never matched against a roster.

Three-way moneylines. A soccer match can be drawn, so its moneyline has three sides: home, draw, away. The fair price is the three-way form of the same method, named multiplicative3: the sharp market's three implied probabilities are each divided by their sum, so the three fair probabilities add to 100%. That name is written on every fair price and on every close, and a three-way alert is only ever graded against a three-way close — a two-way number is never compared with it. Each of the three sides is held to the same 6% phantom line and the same threshold, which is provisional for every soccer league. When the sharp market has no three-sided price, the market consensus reference is the median across its books on each side, the three medians scaled to add to 100% (and a consensus member is graded against the others, as on a two-way market). A draw alert names no team; a home or away alert names the one it is on.

Data. Prices come from a licensed odds feed; the sharp market price arrives through that feed and may lag by minutes. Live scores and the display-only columns come from a second feed and never grade anything. A † on a column header marks a display-only column (bet365, Sharp market): its prices are shown on the same rows, but that column is never alerted and never grades anything. The Sharp market column shows a sharp book's posted price for the row where one is quoted, margin still in, as stored with the alert, and is blank otherwise. It is a display column and is not the number the fair price is computed from: the fair price is built from the sharp market price with the margin removed on tier-A rows and from market consensus on tier-B rows.

Glossary

CLV, closing line value
How much better the price you were alerted to was than the fair price at tip-off. Positive beats the market's final word; negative trails it.
Fair price
A price with the bookmaker's margin removed, so both sides add to 100%. The reference's fair price is the yardstick.
Vig, margin, booksum
The bookmaker's edge: the implied probabilities of both sides add to more than 100%. Devigging removes it.
Multiplicative devig
Divide each implied probability by their sum. The default here.
Shin devig
A method that assigns more of the margin to the longshot. Computed and stored every cycle, not the default.
Reference, tier A, tier B
Tier A: the sharp market price at the same line. Tier B: market consensus, the median across several books. For a consensus member, the tier-B reference excludes the book being graded, at alert time and at the close alike. Every alert carries its tier for good.
EV, expected value
Fair probability × decimal price − 1: the expected return per dollar if the fair price is right.
Suspect edge
A computed edge above 6%. Usually a stale or one-sided price, so it is logged and never posted.
No close
The reference was not quoting the alerted line in the minutes before tip (pulled, moved its line, market removed, or no poll at tip). Counted, shown, never graded.
Held / better / worse / gone
What the alerted book was showing 30 and 60 seconds after the alert.
Decimal, American
2.04 is +104: the two ways of writing the same price. Both are shown.
Snapshot
Every book's price on both sides, the reference and its inputs, captured when the alert fired. The record of what was bettable.